Under the IFAB VAR protocol, a Video Assistant Referee can intervene in a football match only for a “clear and obvious error” or a “serious missed incident” across four core match-changing situations: goals, penalty kick decisions, red cards (including a clearly incorrect second yellow card), and mistaken identity. Beginning with the 2026/27 season, competitions also have the option to let VAR immediately overturn a clearly wrong corner kick before play restarts. Regardless of what the video officials recommend, the on-field referee always makes the final decision.
What counts as a clear and obvious error for VAR?
Football’s lawmakers designed the video review system around the principle of minimal interference for maximum benefit. The VAR is a qualified match official watching broadcast feeds in a Video Operation Room (VOR), not a second referee looking for a better decision when the original call wasn’t clearly wrong.
How high the bar is for an intervention depends on whether the call is subjective or factual. Subjective decisions, such as judging the intensity of a tackle or whether an arm made a defender’s body unnaturally bigger, must meet the strict “clear and obvious error” threshold before VAR steps in.
Factual decisions don’t use the “clear and obvious” test at all. According to the Premier League’s VAR rules, offside positions, whether the ball went out of play, whether a foul happened inside or outside the penalty area, penalty kick encroachment, and mistaken identity are purely factual matters. If replay cameras show an attacker is offside by a fraction of an inch or a foul occurred on the penalty box line rather than outside it, VAR will intervene to correct the call.
The impact on accuracy is measurable. When the Premier League introduced VAR across all 380 fixtures in the 2019/20 season, correct key match decisions rose from 82% in the prior campaign to 94%. Across that season, video officials checked more than 2,400 incidents and overturned 109 decisions, averaging one overturned call every 3.5 matches.
Which match situations can VAR review?
Every incident on the pitch is monitored silently in the background, but the VAR is only allowed to halt play and advise the referee if the event falls into one of four mandatory categories (plus one optional competition rule added for the 2026/27 season):
- Goal or no goal: VAR checks whether the ball completely crossed the goal line, whether the ball went out of play earlier in the move, and whether the attacking team committed a foul, handball, or offside offence in the build-up. If a goal is scored from a penalty kick rebound, VAR also checks for encroachment by an attacking player or offences by the kicker.
- Penalty kick or no penalty kick: Video officials can intervene if a penalty was wrongly awarded (such as when an attacker simulates a foul), if a clear penalty offence was missed by the referee, or if the foul actually took place outside the penalty box. They also check whether the attacking team committed an offence or let the ball go out of play during the build-up to the penalty incident.
- Red cards: This category covers direct sending-off offences—denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity (DOGSO), serious foul play, violent conduct, biting, spitting, and using offensive, insulting, or abusive actions. Following the 2026/27 IFAB Law changes that took effect on July 1, 2026, VAR can also intervene when a player is sent off via a clearly incorrect second yellow card.
- Mistaken identity: If the referee penalises an infringement and shows a yellow or red card to the wrong player, VAR will tell the referee which player actually committed the foul. As of the 2026/27 rules, this applies whether the wrongly booked player belongs to the offending team or the opposing team. The underlying foul itself cannot be reviewed unless it involves a goal, penalty, or red card.
- Clearly incorrect corner kicks (competition option): Starting in the 2026/27 season, leagues and tournaments can choose to allow VAR to overturn a clearly wrongly awarded corner kick (including when the ball went out over the touchline) provided the decision can be changed immediately without delaying the restart. If a team takes the corner quickly, VAR cannot intervene.
Can VAR intervene for yellow cards or routine fouls?
A first yellow card, a routine free kick outside the penalty box, or a throw-in cannot trigger a VAR intervention on its own. Even for second yellow cards, the rule works in only one direction. Under IFAB Law 6, the VAR can step in to cancel a red card caused by a clearly wrong second yellow card, but cannot intervene when the referee misses a cautionable tackle by a player who is already on a booking.
That doesn’t mean yellow cards never come out of a video review. If the referee goes to the pitchside monitor to check a potential red card or penalty kick, they can issue a yellow card if the footage warrants one. For example, if a referee checks a tackle for serious foul play and decides it was reckless rather than endangering an opponent’s safety, they will show a yellow card. Similarly, if an on-field review overturns a penalty because the attacker dived without contact, the referee will book the attacker for simulation.
How far back can VAR rewind play before a goal or penalty?
When checking whether an attacking team committed a foul, handball, or offside before scoring a goal or winning a penalty, VAR cannot rewind the match indefinitely. Under UEFA’s Attacking Phase of Play guidelines and IFAB rules, video officials can only review incidents that occurred during the immediate attacking move that led directly to the goal or penalty.
Once play has stopped and been formally restarted by the players, the window for a VAR review closes for almost every incident prior to that restart. The only exceptions are mistaken identity or a missed sending-off offence involving violent conduct, spitting, biting, or extremely offensive, insulting, or abusive actions, which the referee can still review even after play has restarted.
How do silent checks and on-field reviews work?
Most VAR work happens without stopping the game. During a silent check, the video team reviews camera angles in real time while play continues or during a natural pause. If they spot no clear error, they tell the referee the check is complete (or say nothing at all), and the game moves on.
When a check uncovers a potential error, the referee has two paths depending on the type of call:
- VAR-only review: Used for factual decisions like offside, whether a foul was inside or outside the penalty box, or whether the ball went out of play. The referee accepts the factual information from the VAR over the headset and changes the decision without looking at the screen.
- On-Field Review (OFR): Used for subjective decisions, such as foul severity or handball judgement. The referee makes the rectangular TV screen gesture and walks to the Referee Review Area (RRA) monitor on the touchline to view replays at both slow motion (to see the point of contact) and normal speed (to judge intensity) before making the final call.
Since the 2025/26 season, competitions also have the option under IFAB rules to let referees publicly announce and explain their final decision over the stadium loudspeaker after an on-field review or a lengthy check.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a time limit on how long a VAR review can take?
No. The IFAB VAR protocol states that while reviews should be completed as efficiently as possible, accuracy is always more important than speed, so there is no maximum time limit.
Can a match be replayed if VAR makes a wrong decision or breaks down?
No. Under IFAB rules, a match is never invalidated because of VAR technology malfunctions, wrong decisions involving the VAR, a decision not to review an incident, or an accidental review of a non-reviewable situation.
What happens if a player makes the VAR TV signal at the referee?
Players and coaches are not allowed to demand a video check. Any player, substitute, or team official who excessively makes the rectangular TV screen gesture or enters the Referee Review Area (RRA) must be shown a yellow card. Anyone who enters the Video Operation Room (VOR) is shown a red card and sent off.

