Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Exploit Case

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted a judgment of acquittal on Monday, Nov. 16, clearing MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all federal criminal charges over a $25 million Ethereum trading-bot exploit. The decision in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York permanently closes the prosecution without a retrial, a year after the brothers’ first trial ended in a mistrial.

Judge Clarke dismissed counts of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering in the case, United States v. Peraire-Bueno, according to her Monday ruling. To convict the brothers of wire fraud, prosecutors had to prove they made a material misrepresentation, and Judge Clarke found that none of the government’s theories met that legal standard. Because the money laundering conspiracy count depended on proceeds from the alleged wire fraud, that charge fell once the fraud counts were dismissed.

For Ethereum validators, block builders, and automated traders, the ruling establishes that exploiting software bugs or unwritten trading norms on an open, unregulated blockchain does not constitute federal wire fraud when no false promises are made to counterparties.

Why the wire fraud charges failed

“The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” Judge Clarke wrote in her opinion. “It is simply whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the government, could support wire fraud and related convictions in this case,” she added.

In evaluating how transactions are processed on the blockchain, Judge Clarke described Ethereum as a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.” She found that the bait transactions the brothers placed contained no promise about how their trades would be executed and “were not placed on a regulated market with rules prohibiting this conduct.”

Prosecutors had argued that the brothers deceived network participants by manipulating MEV-Boost, open-source software that lets Ethereum validators outsource the ordering of transactions to specialized block builders. While Judge Clarke wrote that the brothers’ actions “may have frustrated the spirit” of MEV-Boost, she found that frustrating the software’s design was not enough to prove fraud. She also rejected the government’s argument that signing a block header amounted to a promise of honest conduct, noting that prosecutors sought to disregard evidence about the technical meaning of a validator’s commitment and the economic incentives that govern Ethereum block proposals.

Judge Clarke concluded: “Because the Government failed to prove that the Peraire-Buenos made any material misrepresentations in the execution of their scheme, the motion is granted.” In a footnote, she wrote that the prosecution “raises serious due process concerns,” though she declined to rule on that question.

How the 12-second MEV-Boost exploit worked

The criminal case stemmed from an April 2023 exploit targeting automated trading programs known as sandwich bots. These bots pursue maximal extractable value, or MEV, the profit earned by reordering or inserting transactions within a block, by placing their own buy and sell orders on either side of another user’s pending trade.

According to the federal indictment and Judge Clarke’s ruling, Anton and James Peraire-Bueno placed bait transactions designed to lure specific sandwich bots. They then exploited a bug in an MEV-Boost relay’s code to view the bots’ bundled private trades before committing to a block, swapped the bait transactions for trades that sold the tokens instead, and left the bots with about $25 million in losses in roughly 12 seconds.

Federal authorities arrested the brothers in May 2024, alleging they spent months planning the attack, used shell companies and foreign exchanges to move the funds, and searched online for ways to conceal their involvement. Both the government’s indictment and Judge Clarke’s ruling described the case as a “first of its kind” prosecution.

At the brothers’ first trial in Manhattan federal court, an insider testified that the pair had allegedly planned the exploit, while defense attorneys sought to block evidence of their Google searches. After nearly four weeks of trial proceedings and three days of jury deliberations, Judge Clarke declared a mistrial on Nov. 7, 2025, when the jury could not reach a unanimous verdict.

Reactions and legal precedent for open networks

In her ruling, Judge Clarke cited a 2025 federal court decision involving Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg, in which the judge similarly found insufficient evidence of false representations on a decentralized protocol, according to a CoinTelegraph report.

Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of cryptocurrency policy organization Coin Center, called the acquittal “excellent news,” warning against prosecutors’ attempt to enforce an implied standard of honesty on blockchain validators. “Anyone participating in an open network would have to wonder whether prosecutors might later declare their behavior ‘dishonest’ and haul them into court,” Van Valkenburgh said, having previously told The Block that the prosecution was a “massive overstep.”

A spokesperson for Manhattan U.S. Attorney James McDonald declined to comment on the decision, Reuters reported via The Jerusalem Post, and lawyers for Anton and James Peraire-Bueno had no immediate comment. Because Judge Clarke granted a judgment of acquittal, the criminal prosecution is terminated and cannot be retried.

Recent Articles

Related News

Leave A Reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here