The reality behind reality TV shows has always been a topic of debate, and a recent Reddit post has just confirmed our suspicions. Eagle-eyed viewers spotted a screenshot of Indian Idol’s latest episode, featuring guest judge Hema Malini, holding a script that reveals the show’s conversations may not be as spontaneous as we thought. The image, which has been making the rounds on social media, shows Hema Malini, dressed in a white sari, smiling and chatting with someone off-camera, with a script clearly visible in her hand. But what’s interesting is that the script isn’t just an outline of the episode – it includes the exact words she’s supposed to say.
The screenshot, taken from the show’s Holi special episode, which aired earlier this week, has sparked a lively discussion among Redditors. One user commented, “This is really embarrassing. I once worked backstage on a dance reality show, and even Bharti Singh’s comic timing and punchlines, including her saying she loved a particular song and wanting Govinda to dance to it, were all scripted.” Another user chimed in, “Good analysis, this should go viral.” While some expressed surprise, others weren’t shocked, saying, “What did you expect? Reality shows are always scripted to some extent. They need to plan everything.”
The Reddit post has ignited a debate about the authenticity of reality TV shows, with many users weighing in on the topic. Some have defended the practice of scripting, saying it’s necessary for the show’s production, while others have expressed disappointment and frustration. As one user put it, “This has always been the case…most reality shows, including Bigg Boss to some extent, are scripted.” The conversation has also led to a discussion about the role of judges on reality TV shows, with some users praising Hema Malini’s episode on Indian Idol, where she shared stories from her career and life.
Indian Idol, currently in its 15th season, features a judging panel that includes Shreya Ghoshal, Vishal Dadlani, and Badshah, in addition to guest judges like Hema Malini. While the show has been a staple of Indian television for years, the recent revelation has left some fans wondering how much of what they see on screen is real and how much is scripted. As the debate continues, one thing is clear – the line between reality and scripted TV is often blurred, and it’s up to the audience to decide what they want to believe.
What do you think about reality TV shows being scripted?
- Do you think it’s necessary for the show’s production?
- Are you disappointed to learn that your favorite reality show might be scripted?
- Do you think judges on reality TV shows should be more transparent about the scripting process?
