Technology giant Apple is escalating its legal battle against the European Union’s Digital Markets Act (DMA), claiming the landmark regulations impose “extremely onerous and intrusive” restrictions that jeopardize user privacy and security.
The company voiced these objections before the EU Court of Justice, asserting the obligations violate its market rights and disregard property protections.
Apple is simultaneously appealing a €500 million (approximately $535 million USD) fine imposed by the EU for a previous DMA violation. The penalty stemmed from a breach of the Digital Markets Regulation.
The European Commission, in its defense, immediately rejected Apple’s arguments. It maintains that the tech firm’s “absolute control” over its iPhone ecosystem enables “abnormal profits” in complementary markets.
The Commission stated that Apple alone “holds the keys to its private garden,” dictating who can offer products and services to iPhone users. It argued that competitors are at a disadvantage and cannot compete on equal terms.
Apple’s legal efforts encompass three distinct challenges to the DMA’s provisions.
One primary area of dispute involves requirements for interoperability between iOS and rival devices. Apple contends these mandates pose risks to privacy, security, and the company’s intellectual property.
Another challenge targets the inclusion of the App Store under DMA rules. Apple argues its application marketplace does not qualify as a “single service” as defined by the legislation.
Finally, Apple is resisting the EU’s attempt to scrutinize iMessage. The company claims the messaging service does not directly generate revenue.
Despite aligning with some EU demands, Apple continues to seek a fundamental review to weaken the DMA’s overall scope. The EU Court of Justice has yet to issue a decision on the matter.